From “I Scream Sandwich: Inspired Recipes for the Ultimate Frozen Treat” by Jennie Schacht (Stewart, Tabori & Change, 2013)
(Note from Jill: For more about this charming, adorable, ice creamalicious book, read this post, Cooking the books: I Scream Sandwich!)
This is my go-to sandwich when I am jonesing for one and there are none stashed away in the freezer. Sometimes I hope not to find a sandwich there, just so I can make this one, which delights with warm toast, cool ice cream, and the reassuring flavors of childhood. With ice cream awaiting in your freezer, a sandwich need never be more than a toaster away.
I make these up one at a time when the mood strikes. If you’re hosting a child’s sleep-over party or have family in town for the holidays, make all twelve at once for an easy and memorable breakfast or midnight snack.
Peanut butter is personal: Choose creamy for a smooth ice cream or chunky for more texture. In either case, look for a natural-style peanut butter made from only peanuts (salt optional), with no sweeteners or gums. I prefer a mild honey such as clover or orange blossom for this ice cream.
Makes (up to) 12 sandwiches
- 1 cup heavy cream
- 2/3 cup (160 grams) natural peanut butter
- 1/4 teaspoon kosher salt
- 2 tablespoons tapioca starch or cornstarch
- 1/4 cup (84 grams) mild-flavored honey
- 1/2 cup (100 grams) granulated sugar
- 2 cups whole milk
- 1/2 teaspoon pure vanilla extract
- 1 to 12 slices good-quality sandwich bread, such as challah, bakery white, or honey whole wheat
- Unsalted butter, for spreading on the toast (optional)
- 1 to 12 tablespoons Berry Ribbon (see book for recipe) or berry jam or fruit spread
Whisk 1/2 cup of the milk with the sugar, honey, tapioca, and salt in a medium saucepan until no lumps remain. Stir in the remaining 1 1/2 cups milk.
Heat the mixture over medium-high heat, stirring with a heatproof spatula, until it begins to steam and slightly bubble at the edges. Adjust to a simmer and cook, stirring constantly, until the mixture thickens to the consistency of a cream sauce, 2 to 3 minutes longer; do not fully boil.
Off the heat, add the peanut butter, give it a minute or two to soften, then stir until smooth and well blended. Stir in the cream and vanilla.
Transfer the mixture to a metal bowl set over a larger bowl of ice and water. Stir occasionally until the mixture is cool, taking care not to slosh water into the bowl. Cover and refrigerate until very cold, at least 2 hours. Transfer the bowl to the freezer for the last half hour before spinning it.
Freeze the mixture in an ice cream maker according to the manufacturer’s directions. When it is ready, transfer the ice cream to a chilled container, cover, and freeze until firm, at least 4 hours or overnight.
SANDWICH! For each sandwich, toast 1 slice of bread until it is medium dark. Trim the crusts and butter the bread if you wish. Cut the slice in half, either crosswise or diagonally, as you would a sandwich.
Spread 1 tablespoon of jam on one toast half. Scoop and spread 1/4 cup slightly softened ice cream across the other half. Sandwich the two together and enjoy while the toast is warm.
TAKE IT EASY For each sandwich, mix 2 teaspoons of peanut butter with 1 teaspoon of honey and swirl into a scoop of softened vanilla ice cream. Use your favorite jam jelly, or fruit spread in place of the Berry Ribbon.
DRESS IT UP For extra peanut punch, press the sides of the sandwiches in Honey-Roasted Peanut Brittle (see book for recipe).