Cornmeal-Crusted Petrale with Tomato-Tarragon Relish /

If you’re counting ingredients, you’re doing it wrong

Bon Appetit’s recent “simple” issue—where every recipe in the magazine used five ingredients or less—touched a nerve.

I get where they’re coming from. People think few ingredients = easy. And easy is good, right?

Bon Appetit isn’t alone wanting to capitalize on that thinking. I’ve had more than a handful of clients ask me to develop recipes that use no more than x-number of ingredients.

Plus, Bon Appetit has an ulterior motive. They’ve introduced a new corner of their web site called Basically, which repurposes some of their content under a “learn to cook” sort of banner. So they’re waving the simplicity flag as part of promoting their new thing. I get it.

And yet, counting ingredients? It’s wrong.

Why? Two reasons.

One, because few ingredients = easy infers that lots of ingredients = hard. And that’s not true.

It’s not hard to shop for, and then measure out, a few more ingredients. It takes more time, yes, but that’s not the same as it being difficult.

That’s an important distinction in our harried world where everyone is pressed for time. Yes, sometimes things take our time, which is sometimes precious. But that doesn’t mean they’re difficult. I mean, a monkey can fold laundry. Or stir risotto.

So, taking time ≠ being hard.

Plus, if you have a decently stocked pantry, extra ingredients don’t necessarily mean more shopping. And extra ingredients don’t always mean more measuring.

So in addition to more ingredients ≠ hard, more ingredients ≠ more time—at least not by definition.

Cornmeal-Crusted Petrale with Tomato-Tarragon Relish /

But the other, way more important reason counting ingredients is wrong is if you want to evaluate the ease and simplicity of a recipe, not to mention the pleasure it might bring you, counting ingredients puts the focus in the entirely wrong place.

For joy in the kitchen and delight at the table, look for recipes that are “easy” in that they emphasize a few quality ingredients and then prepare them simply, so as to enhance their already-wonderful qualities.

That’s worth repeating. No fastidious counting of ingredients is going to guarantee simply delicious food. Because that’s a product of good things—tomatoes at their peak, chicken that tastes like chicken, delicately sweet seafood, flavorful herbs, etc—in intriguing and complementary combinations that judiciously accentuate the positive.

Number of ingredient be darned.

How can you spot one of those recipes?

Look for produce in season. For flavorful, responsibly-sourced meats, poultry, and seafood. Look for secondary ingredients that intrigue but don’t distract. And appealing combination of flavors, colors, and textures.

Those kinds of recipes, inherently, don’t use a ton of ingredients. But if it took eight ingredients to make that happen, would that be so terrible? Or ten? Or thirteen, as in this Cornmeal-Crusted Petrale with Tomato-Tarragon Relish?

I think not.

Cornmeal-Crusted Petrale with Tomato-Tarragon Relish /

Like this? Please share it or subscribe.

Looking for something special?