Cause a revolution with cranberry relish

November 18, 2010


Of the entire calendar year, there’s no meal that’s more traditional than Thanksgiving. And by “traditional” I mean constrained.

You have to have the turkey. You have to have the stuffing. And the cranberry sauce. And the pumpkin pie.

And you have to have potatoes. But what kind of potatoes? My husband comes from a must-have-mashed-potatoes family, while I love sweet potatoes for Thanksgiving. To make everyone happy, I have to make both. (What’s the emoticon for a frustrated grimace?)

Then along with the must-have-or-else components, at some tables there are must-ways to make them, preparations that are simply not open for discussion.

The cranberry sauce must be jellied. The stuffing must have sausage and chestnuts. The X must have Y (fill in your family requirements here).

A couple of years ago, though, I shook things up, just a bit. In addition to my family’s usual cranberry sauce – I didn’t want to cause a major revolt, just a minor stir – I also made an amazingly good, amazingly easy-to-make Cranberry and Horseradish Relish that my friends Lenny and Brigid introduced me to.

Maybe I was acting crazy. But I could argue that it’s patriotic to mix things up on Thanksgiving.

I mean, weren’t the original American settlers escaping the dominance of the old country to express their religious freedom? Absolutely. Freedom of expression, that’s what this country was founded on.

Why, you’d be positively un-American if you made a “traditional” Thanksgiving!

So slip some blue cheese into that stuffing – the Pilgrims would approve! Make roasted root vegetables instead of potatoes! Sprinkle that bird with herbes de Provence! Blanket it with proscuitto! Or flip the bird the bird – serve lasagna!

But more importantly, make sure that your Thanksgiving isn’t so much about the meal as it is about all the gifts you have – first and foremost, the loved ones at your table. That would be really revolutionary – focusing on all there is to be thankful for instead of how moist the turkey is.

And my cranberry relish? Everyone said it was so good, they didn’t need the jellied stuff ever again.

P.S., added the next day, My friend Brigid reminds me that the original version of this recipe is actually Susan Stamberg’s (yes, NPR’s Susan Stamberg!) mom’s cranberry relish. Credit where credit is due!

(Here’s the recipe for it.)


Cranberry recipes I’ve developed for Bon Appetit magazine:

Cranberry and Vanilla Bean Sorbet

Basic Cranberry Sauce

Cinnamon and Clove Cranberry Sauce

Cranberry Sauce with Vanilla Bean and Cardamom

Quince and Cranberry Sauce

Pineapple Cranberry Sauce with Chiles and Cilantro

2 thoughts on “Cause a revolution with cranberry relish

  1. Jennie Schacht

    So true, Jill! Problem is, when I change things up someone always wants the traditional version, so the menu just keeps getting longer and longer. This year I’ve asked everyone to bring something that will make it feel like Thanksgiving for them. (Coordinating, of course, so we don’t end up with 12 bowls of cranberry-orange relish.) That way I know everyone’s hankerings are covered and I can make what I want!

  2. Jill Post author

    I get it about the menu getting longer and longer, and I love your brilliant solution!

    Sometimes I wonder, if we love all these things so much, why do we only eat them once a year? On the other hand, maybe because they’re rarities, they’re that much more special. Still pondering…

    Thanks for your comment, Jennie.

Leave a Reply

Your email will not be published. An asterisk indicates a required field.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.